New York,

In 1991 my father was approved for an Visa applicatio through marriage, after an investigation by the US Embassy in the Dominican Republic in 1993, it was determined that the marriage was fraudulent and needless to say the application approval was revoked......... back in 2004 I applied to bring him to the US , the application was approved but after every requirement was met and after I went to the visa interview in DR in 2009, he was given a paper stating that his visa had been denied because of the previously mentioned fraudulent marriage....now, what can I do, or what options do I have in this situation, I think that an appeal on the first denial would not make sense because of the time lapse, but is there a pardon he ca apply for or a fine that can be paid?... please advise, thanks in advance for your time.