Hi Folks,
I am a regular Caltrain rider (State of California) and a current monthly pass holder. While I have been asked countless times to show a ticket, I just recently failed the “proof of purchase” (POP) test for the first time.
I know, this post is similar to many others who have asked about the possibility of overturning Caltrain fare evasion citations, but I appreciate the help nonetheless. I hope you will share any advice you may have even if it has already appeared elsewhere.
Last month I boarded the train with an eight-ride ticket that had been properly validated. However, due to my general disorganization, I could not find the ticket that I had dropped into my briefcase when the agent came by.
What is likely to be the most effective strategy in court for beating this or at least getting the fine lowered? Is there any point in explaining these facts to the judge - -that I’m not guilty of fare evasion in the literal sense of the word but am only guilty of being disorganized and not putting my ticket in my wallet? I have the usual proof: evidence of a regular string of ticket purchases, a credit card statement showing I purchased an eight-ride the week preceding the citation, current holder of a monthly pass, etc. From what I've read here, anything short showing a valid ticket to the conductor at the time will fail the POP test.
So I’m at the point that I need to make decisions. Should I go to the court house before the due date? Should I request an arraignment or a court trail? If it comes to trial, how should I plead?
Thank you in advance for your assistance!
Bob

