New York State- We own a property (road) over which 6 neighbors have the right of "ingress and egress" to reach their cottages. In April, we had work done on the road because of huge ruts, and a general degradation of the beginning of the road, and only on the portion which benefits everyone equally. All neighbors were happy to contribute to the maintenance, except one. We have now received a letter from their attorney stating they have no responsibility to pay, and will not pay, their portion. Their deed refers only to ingress/egress, but at least one of the other neighbors has a mention in his deed for contributing to the maintenance. Where can we go from here? I know I can get an attorney to send the back and forth letters, but would prefer to escalate this.
1. Is there a legal responsibility on their part to pay their portion of the road maintenance?
2. If so, what court would I take this to? Would a small claims court handle this? (It is only $319.00)
Thanks for any help you can give.

