My question involves criminal law for the state of: California
My twelve-year old son was caught shoplifting a bouncy ball from Rite Aid in Half Moon Bay, CA. The ball was worth about $1.50 and this was his first offense. The gentlemen that stopped him called me at work and told me to come pick him up. When I got there, he had me sign the infamous peice of paper, agreeing to pay charges of anywhere from $50-$500. I was told that they weren't going to prosecute and that he was even going to just let him go but that his manager made him keep him to teach him a lesson, which I understand and can appreciate. He also told me that he felt the fine would be closer to the lower end since it was just a bouncy ball and a 12 year-olds first offense.
However, over a month after the incident, I received the letter demanding $300. It was sent from a law firm in Florida. I find this to be outrageous considering the circumstances and would almost prefer that they proceed with their civil matter - will they do so over a $1.50 bouncy ball? I called the law firm and was told that this is a state mandated fine and that it has nothing to do with what was taken or his age. She said he can make 8 payments of $37.50 per month, which is his entire allowance between my house and his father's house.
Any suggestions? My husband thinks we should let them take it to court, but will I wind up paying more? I really want him to pay and learn a valuable lesson, so I don't exactly want to bail him out - but $300!!!!???
Any advise is appreciated. Thanks ~

