Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2
Results 11 to 19 of 19
  1. #11
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    38,867

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    I was reading one of the sites this is posted and they spoke of e coli levels in area water which apparently they believe were traceable to this guys property.



    This was in LaPorte county Indiana if the gossip was correct. The landowner did sue for the trespass but was rebuffed by the judge.

    Not sure of any of the facts, simply repeating what some of the folks were posting.

    Did anybody notice the sheriff did not enter the property (short of the minor thing at the driveway) even after the woman was cruising all over the land?

    It would seem if the woman did have rights to be there, given the aggressiveness of the landowner, he would have had rights to accompany the woman (for her safety). I don;t thing the sheriff was too confident of the womans right to be there either. I kind of think he told her she was on her own.

  2. #12
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Ohio
    Posts
    1,094

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    Quote Quoting jk
    View Post
    I was reading one of the sites this is posted and they spoke of e coli levels in area water which apparently they believe were traceable to this guys property.



    This was in LaPorte county Indiana if the gossip was correct. The landowner did sue for the trespass but was rebuffed by the judge.

    Not sure of any of the facts, simply repeating what some of the folks were posting.

    Did anybody notice the sheriff did not enter the property (short of the minor thing at the driveway) even after the woman was cruising all over the land?

    It would seem if the woman did have rights to be there, given the aggressiveness of the landowner, he would have had rights to accompany the woman (for her safety). I don;t thing the sheriff was too confident of the womans right to be there either. I kind of think he told her she was on her own.
    According to the CDC health inspectors (employed by our county health departments have Consitutional 'police' power. They are front line inspectors of threats of bioterrorism as well as those who don't abide by laws that protect public from health hazards (ie drinking water contaminated with animal feces or decomposing matter). You cannot sue them, they have immunity.

    The Sheriff is obligated to watch the immediate threat to the inspector. My guess the inspector had done sufficient homework before arriving on the property and knew just where she wanted to go.

    Also, he may have been making sure the property owner didn't leave.

    But my first reaction to the deputy was he didn't have any idea what he was doing.

  3. #13
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    38,867

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    Quote Quoting deadlock
    View Post
    Also, he may have been making sure the property owner didn't leave.

    But my first reaction to the deputy was he didn't have any idea what he was doing.
    ok DL, I can see most of your post but what right would the officer have to prevent the property owner from leaving?

    and I definately agree about the sheriff.

    I still have a hard time believing or accepting the health inspector had any legal rights to trespass to inspect the property unless there was just cause. I can tell you this, that if an inspector did come on my property without permission or warrant, I would be here looking for aid to get my ass out of jail. I would not allow it until i could no longer resist it.

    It is my property and you better have a good and articulatable justification to enter my property. She failed to justify her inspection. I will not accept anybody wandering willy nilly about my property without that justification.

    and no, I am not a closet anarchist, merely a person that believes in the rights of the citizens of this country.

    btw; I was cruising around trying to find out anything about this. I found a site that reported the property was condemned and the guy was trying to sell it for $22k (I believe the acceptable currency was gold I didn't bother to read to much in depth)

  4. #14
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Ohio
    Posts
    1,094

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    Quote Quoting jk
    View Post
    ok DL, I can see most of your post but what right would the officer have to prevent the property owner from leaving?

    and I definately agree about the sheriff.

    I still have a hard time believing or accepting the health inspector had any legal rights to trespass to inspect the property unless there was just cause. I can tell you this, that if an inspector did come on my property without permission or warrant, I would be here looking for aid to get my ass out of jail. I would not allow it until i could no longer resist it.

    It is my property and you better have a good and articulatable justification to enter my property. She failed to justify her inspection. I will not accept anybody wandering willy nilly about my property without that justification.

    and no, I am not a closet anarchist, merely a person that believes in the rights of the citizens of this country.

    btw; I was cruising around trying to find out anything about this. I found a site that reported the property was condemned and the guy was trying to sell it for $22k (I believe the acceptable currency was gold I didn't bother to read to much in depth)
    Of course we all have the right to privacy and to receive notice of inspection as a result of a complaint. Public health is civil not criminal and their actions are in the interest of the public to prevent disease, harm, etc. Not to punish prior acts. The officer wasn't there to arrest the guy, he was there to protect the inspector.

    It was a joke guy with the camera was going to leave.

    The officer did appear to be blocking the driveway as if the guy was going to "escape". The video I saw had him operating that camera and no way was he going anywhere. She was not there to press charges against the guy. Public health doesn't work like that.

    http://www2a.cdc.gov/phlp/publaw.asp
    Click on "Federal: Public Health Service Act"
    Scroll down to III General Power and duties of public health service.

    I agree with you that you wouldn't want someone arriving on your property to snoop. But tell me what you would do if-
    you live in a rural area and your land is part of a development that borders on a farm with livestock. There is a flood and animals have died on the farm. You don't know what happened to them but about three months later there are small pools of water the kids wade in and they get sick. Blood vessels on the backs of their legs are streaked all the way to the knees. Fevers.

    Who ya gonna call? No. Not ghostbusters.

    The public health department isn't going to arrive on the neighbor's property unannounced. They are there to protect the public from disease and good cause is the case of e coli infections the kids recently acquired. They try to find the source and clean it up.

    My experience with them is they say exactly that. There has been an outbreak of ... and several children have gotten ... We are attempting to find the source in the area. And they ask permission to look around on your property.

    Check out the CDC website. You'll see that they take no legal action against anyone. It is frustrating to alot of people who want someone sanctioned by the CDC.

  5. #15
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    38,867

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    but this woman would not tell the land owner why she wanted to inspect the area. That wouldn't go far at my house.

    and as far as your link, I saw nothing applicable to this situation or powers that were granted to allow such an invasion. I may have missed it but I didn;t see it myself.

  6. #16
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Ohio
    Posts
    1,094

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    Quote Quoting jk
    View Post
    but this woman would not tell the land owner why she wanted to inspect the area. That wouldn't go far at my house.
    She was there the day before. He gave her a hard time. I couldn't hear anything she said because of his mouth running constantly. He never let her answer a question or say anything (except that she wasn't going to tell him her last name). If it were me, I would have been frustrated with his behaving like that. Telling her he was going to sue her for trespassing.

    Think he'd act like that if a gas line was leaking on his property? He'd be complaining the inspector was trespassing? Foolish.

  7. #17
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    28,906

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    The administrative search exception to the Fourth Amendment originally grew out of highly regulated businesses (e.g., food service), where inspection was made a condition of doing business. In contrast with a criminal investigation where individualized suspicion is required, administrative searches do not require individualized suspicion (e.g., every restaurant is subject to periodic health inspection, no matter how clean it looks.) Under current law, even where there is a significant law enforcement aspect to the inspection, you do not need a search warrant to conduct an administrative search.

    If a health inspector is trying to trace the source of e. coli contamination, the inspector will attempt to determine sources of the contamination. In a rural area like this, an obvious possible source is a septic field. For the inspector to then investigate area properties, with a focus on those where there is excavation in the area of septic tanks or fields, is legitimate.

    Similarly, although apparently not relevant in this specific case, if permitting is required before such excavation is allowed, a government inspector can investigate unauthorized investigation, cite the owner for excavating without a permit, and even get a court order prohibiting further work until a permit was properly obtained. And, of course, there would ordinarily be an inspection of the finished work. No warrants required.

  8. #18
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    38,867

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    didn't mean to sound argumentative to all and I do understand what y'all are saying. I just don;t agree with it and that's my right as a US citizen dammit


    The odd part is the sheriff did not come onto the property. As protection for the health worker, I would presume he had every right to accompany the woman. Not in an investigatory manner but as protection for the woman only. Not sure how any evidence seen would be handled but that is another thread.

    Obviously, this entire situation was handled poorly. I believe the sheriff did not know what actually was allowable and what wan;t. Both of the gov. employees should have had more direction and support from the local district attorney;s office or even the states AG. This could have gotten real ugly if the landowner was just a bit more off kilter mentally. If a gov employee chooses to take an action, they should be very well informed as to it's correctness and be able to articulate that to the citizen involved. The sheriff simply repeating the "if you don;t have anything to hide" BS makes him look like he feels he is in the wrong. He needs to be able to state support for the actions, even if that meant coming back a different day.

    want a laugh? spellcheck accepted "y'all" and "dammit" without question. The program writer must be from the south

  9. #19
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Ohio
    Posts
    1,094

    Default Re: Trespass by a Health Inspector

    "Wisdom lies
    neither in fixity
    nor in change,
    but in the dialectic
    between the two."

    Octavio Paz

    1. Sponsored Links
       

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2

Similar Threads

  1. Unethical Realtor and Inspector
    By amccoy in forum Buying, Selling and Conveying Real Estate
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 10-22-2010, 07:32 AM
  2. Trespassing: Can You Charge a Township Inspector with Trespassing
    By RexRudd in forum Criminal Charges
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 06-09-2008, 09:03 AM
  3. Building Inspector Misconduct
    By Evga in forum Buying, Selling and Conveying Real Estate
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 06-08-2008, 02:27 PM
  4. Home Inspector Missed Something Huge
    By iggie82 in forum Construction, Repair and Renovation
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 06-03-2008, 05:25 AM
  5. Home Inspector Did Not Do His Job
    By lisa0801 in forum Construction, Repair and Renovation
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 05-26-2008, 07:27 AM
 
 
Sponsored Links

Legal Help, Information and Resources