Results 1 to 3 of 3
  1. #1

    Default Contract Never Officially Terminated but Work Stopped, No Payment Made

    My question involves labor and employment law for the state of: NC

    Hello, this is my problem: I was hired to illustrate a children's picture book for a publishing company in NY. Five months into the project, I was told to start over with a new style that was completely different from the style I had been using to begin with. Basically I was told to take it down from detailed compositions to extremely minimal, flat 'baby' drawings.

    (Here I need to add that the first picture book I'd illustrated for the company had become popular, and I was attempting to recreate that success with this book by using the style I'd used for the first book.)

    I had already had a lot of trouble with the president of the company 'changing her mind' during the course of a project, during the prior books I illustrated for the company, and I was not eager to "start over" after putting so much work into the style I'd started with, figuring she might keep "changing her mind" and never paying me, indefinitely. I received the initial payment, but had not gotten the second payment yet, which was due, since I'd completed the draft (three payments were expected altogether). In the meantime, my father died suddenly, and I put off dealing with the publisher due to the great stress surrounding the event. The president emailed me and told me to not "screw up" my relationship with her company (within a few weeks). At this point I contacted her via phone and let her know I was going through great stress and was not happy about having to start a book over and knowing five months of hard work had been wasted. She suggested we "scrap the whole project and start over with a new book". I told her, in a courteous tone, I would prefer if future contracts would allow for me to get paid for extra work if I were asked to "start over" mid-project. She sounded very upbeat, said she wanted to "help" me, and said she would call back in three weeks. She never called back, she never emailed, and around a year later I saw the book I had been working on had been published with another illustrator. The contract was never officially terminated. This took place in 2012.

    First, I want to know, did I have the right to demand the second payment, as promised by the contract?

    Second, I need to call the company and ask about some things, but I am uneasy due to the fact that I have not communicated with them since that last phone call, and I am fairly certain the president dislikes me (in spite of the fact I gave the company good work). Could the president sue me or demand reparations for the fact I did not contact her for several weeks after my father died, at this point? What does the president of this company have the right to do, at this point, in terms of lashing out at me? (I will add that I know it was not good manners to not contact them, but I was so distraught I did not feel capable of making good decisions, and I was admittedly rather angry that the time I'd wasted trying to craft a really good picture book for this company could have been better spent with my father, not that that means anything from a legal perspective.)

    I really do not know how this works. All I know is there was no official termination. She simply said she would contact me with the new contract/project, and then nothing. (I will add that she also told me she wanted me to keep illustrating books for the company indefinitely, during the phone call. This sort of two-faced interaction baffles me.)

    I checked Glassdoor employee reviews and discovered that she treats all her employees in a consistently terrible manner, especially the competent employees, and that the company is "extremely dysfunctional", so that was a comfort, in a way.

    Thank you for any advice.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Behind a Desk

    Default Re: Contract Never Officially Terminated but Work Stopped, No Payment Made

    If this occurred in 2012, then it appears that you have waited far too long to take legal action based upon the possible breach of contract. Read this.

    If your hope is to resume working for the company after that five year break, you can reach out to the company. I cannot tell you whether you would have to work through or with the same person, or if there is another person through whom you could work -- that's up to the company, and whether or not the person still works there.

  3. #3

    Default Re: Contract Never Officially Terminated but Work Stopped, No Payment Made

    Thank you Mr. Knowitall. I appreciate the link; it is very informative. I do not wish to pursue legal action against this company, but rather, I want to know if the president can pursue legal action against me for a perceived offense, at this point. I looked up the statute of limitations chart for NY, and according to the chart, NY has a 6-year limit for pursuing action concerning a contract. So the president of the publishing company would be operating under NY law, even if I signed the contract (physically) in NC? It looks like the time limit is almost up, in NY, for legal action concerning this contract. Is this chart accurate?

    Assuming it is accurate, when am I safe to say that this president is outside of the time limit for pursuing legal action against me? If she decided I had breached the contract by not "starting over" or by not contacting her right away after my father passed, when would the official beginning be, to the time-limit countdown?

    I am sorry if this seems paranoid, but I am under the impression that this president is not mentally balanced. I do need to contact the company, nonetheless.

    1. Sponsored Links

Similar Threads

  1. Fraud: Buyer Said Goods Don't Work, Stopped Payment - Is it a Crime
    By Juan12lpz in forum Criminal Charges
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 11-02-2012, 01:10 AM
  2. Contracts and Agreements: Contract Terminated Despite Quality of Work
    By creativethoughts in forum Independent Contractors
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 02-15-2012, 05:54 PM
  3. Payment Disputes: Stopped Work After Non-Payment, Receiving Threats, Can They Do Anything
    By billMillon500 in forum Independent Contractors
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 12-31-2011, 06:13 PM
  4. Compensation and Overtime: Payment Issue for Online Contract Work
    By makaveli120 in forum Employment and Labor
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 03-25-2009, 09:58 AM
  5. Getting Fired: Was I 'officially' terminated?
    By aspire2hi in forum Employment and Labor
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 06-07-2006, 08:53 AM
Sponsored Links

Legal Help, Information and Resources