I hold an FFL.
Given that you're in NY, which isn't known for having lenient firearm laws, I would not give the shotgun to someone who lives in the home with you.
I would advise you to take it to a local dealer, either for a straight-up sale, or to put on consignment. Typically you'll get more cash from a consignment but you have to wait a while until the gun sells.
ATF provides a list of all licensees and their contact info at https://www.atf.gov/firearms/listing...sees-ffls-2015 if you want to call around and ask for their consignment rates.

