Quote Quoting cdwjava
View Post
If the USSC wants to reverse itself, it has that right. We shall see. But, so far (and I am on a laptop and not at home or the office where I have my resources) the standard of case law is that unreasonably prolonging the detention is unlawful, and once you have completed your business you cannot just hold onto a person absent some new reasonable suspicion to detain further.
reverse itself? care to show an opinion that they would be reversing?

You are arguing any detention after the justification for the stop has been completed is unreasonable. The 8th doesn't agree with you. It appears they are taking a stand that a de minimus detention is not unreasonable. That is what the SCOTUS is hearing. The issue of waiting for the dog to be brought to the scene deals with a reasonable detention based on the justification for the stop. This new issue is simply; how long can they continue to detain you without any reasonable suspicion and so far the 8th has said 7-8 minutes is not unreasonable.