"When an Appeals Examiner’s Decision is appealed to the Commission, the Commission obtains the complete file from the Idaho Department of Labor. The file includes all of the documents considered by the Appeals Examiner and the tape recording of the Appeals Examiner’s hearing. The case is assigned to a referee who reviews these documents and the tape. Based on this review, the referee prepares a written decision for approval by the Commissioners. Neither the Commissioners nor the referee is bound by the findings and the conclusions of the Appeals Examiner.
From that there was a referee and from the published worker's comp decisions there are at least three commissioners. You're asserting that a minimum of four probably very smart people were duped by a pastry manager and an internet poster with zero experience in ID UI matters who doesn't know what she's talking about. If that's true, then ID has much worse problems then the OP collecting UI benefits she's not entitled to.