Quote Quoting Mr. Knowitall
View Post
First and foremost, nothing you have posted indicates that $50,000, $35,000 or $85,000 would be excessive.

Second, it sounds like the original case was dismissed, and odds are the bail from that original case was refunded to the bondsman. It's unlikely that he sat around for three years without making any effort to get his money back.

Third, you were able to quickly post bail, undermining the argument that the amount was unreasonably high.

Fourth, despite having many opportunities to do so, the U.S. Supreme Court has never explicitly incorporated the Eighth Amendment's provision pertaining to bail to the states, with only dicta (statements not part of the court's holding, and thus not of precedential value) supporting that position, so your only recourse is through (a) state law, (b) the state constitution, or (c) battling the issue up to the U.S. Supreme Court and convincing them to revisit the issue and clarify their position.

The rest depends on the details, so if you're serious about pursuing this you'll need to discuss them with a civil rights lawyer.
The original $50,000 bond wasn't released until after my second arrest according to documentary evidence I have from the bond company. This means that the original $50,000 bond was still a good bond at the time of my second arrest, which means that I was arrested for a second time even though there was a good $50,000 bond that was already in place for my release. This means that there was no need for a second arrest with an additional $35,000 bond required, since there was already a good $50,000 bond in place for my release that satisfied the $35,000 bond requirement. This means that excessive bail was charged since I ended up posting a total of $85,000 in bonds (consisting of a $50,000 bond from the first arrest and a $35,000 bond from the second arrest) for a case where the bond requirement was only $35,000 when the DA filed its charges.

I never claimed the bail was unreasonably high. I have no idea where you got that impression. I am simply claiming that I was forced to post $85,000 in bonds for a case that only had a $35,000 bond requirement. That is a $50,000 unnecessary excess. I also stayed an extra day in jail for an unecessary second arrest.

The Supreme Court not clarifying its position I have no idea about.

You say I should dicsuss the matter with a civil rights lawyer. Are you not a civil rights lawyer? I thought this was the police misconduct category where civil rights/police misconduct attorneys are?