$180 is not a "first time" and the prosecutor and judge know this.
You will receive a Civil Demand in the mail. Count on one from each store you stole from. These are separate from the Criminal Charges you may face.
Macy's tends to file criminal charges. Hard to tell by your post, but I would guess being busted in a mall - you will be receiving a court date. And yes, a criminal record. A consultation to a Criminal Defense Attorney would be a good idea...

