
Quoting
RexLan
I think your dislike of the neighbor is clouding your focus. I have had a similar issue with the butt head on MY road and there is nothing I can do about it. He has $$$ too.
Where you put the gate is immaterial. If he is smart all he needs to do is call the sheriff and you are in trouble. You will be promptly told to open the gate or you will get arrested. Additionally, if you have a gate and he has an emergency you're really hung out.
You purchased the property with this knowledge and you apparently did not do your due diligence. It is not reasonable to come back after the fact with a big pissed off and look to get satisfaction. That sounds harsh but unfortunately these deadbeats always seem to win.
What the seller did or did not do with this neighbor is none of your concern or business. Your only concern is your access to your property from the state road and the representations (written) that the seller made with you.
I suspect you will get a pretty good slap with your approach and he will get a free pass and a lot of assistance. Be it fair or not, that is the reality. On the other hand, it will be great if you can win this.
Dogs ... oh yes I know about those also. Why would he need to shoot your dog? Certainly you keep it at home right?
Good luck and hopefully you will get this resolved. Come back and share the outcome.