Using Information from a Proprietary Publication in a Public Domain Publication
I want to use some information from a proprietary publication in a public domain publication.
1. Can I do that if I put the proprietary publication in the references?
2. If so, what happens when someone removes the references?
Isn't anything public domain which descends from a public domain work?
Re: Using Information from a Proprietary Publication in a Public Domain Publication
What do you mean by proprietary? What do you mean by information?
Adding "credit" generally doesn't make illegal acts legal except when there is a license that authorizes to do things provided you give credit.
Re: Using Information from a Proprietary Publication in a Public Domain Publication
You cannot use property owned by someone else without their permission.
Re: Using Information from a Proprietary Publication in a Public Domain Publication
Quote:
Quoting
flyingron
What do you mean by proprietary? What do you mean by information?
Adding "credit" generally doesn't make illegal acts legal except when there is a license that authorizes to do things provided you give credit.
Proprietary: appeared in a scientific journal, for example; or in a book and not public domain.
Information: not a word-by-word quotation, but review and usage of a little part of the contents of the proprietary publication in other words.
Scientists usually use information from other works when they write a publication,
and then mention the references in the references section of the publication.
As far as I know, they act legally if they mention the references,
but they do not act legally if they do not mention the appropriate references (plagiarism or something?)
Thus, if I would act like a scientist and write a public domain work with some non-public domain references,
what would happen?
Re: Using Information from a Proprietary Publication in a Public Domain Publication
It depends on the facts. You're being cagey, so we can't answer - and I suspect that you're not even in the U.S.
Consult a lawyer in your nation with your actual plan.